If you had a teacher who could no longer teach because of a disability and you moved them into a support role, could it be discriminatory not to continue to pay them their previous teacher's salary permanently? According to a recent Employment Appeal Decision, yes, potentially it could.
What happened?
Under the Equality Act 2010 employers must look at what adjustments can be made to help remove any disadvantage to disabled employees and implement those that are considered to be "reasonable".
In this recent interesting case, G4S Cash Solutions (UK) Ltd v Powell, a disabled employee who could no longer carry out his job as an engineer due to his disability, took on a more junior role. He initially continued to receive his higher engineer's salary which he thought was a long term arrangement, but was later dismissed when he refused to accept a lower rate of pay reflecting the more junior role.
What did the Tribunal decide?
The Employment Appeal Tribunal decided that the employer was required to continue to pay their employee on his higher engineer's salary on a permanent basis because it considered it was a reasonable adjustment to continue to do so. It did, however, comment that the employer had substantial resources and so would not be "reasonable" in all cases.
Why is this case important?
Whilst this case wasn't concerned with a school, the unexpected decision reminds us that the law in this area is always changing. When you are faced with a disabled employee who cannot undertake their job, serious consideration needs to be given to all adjustments that can be made and whether those adjustments may be considered "reasonable" in the circumstances. It reminds us of the extent of the burden placed on employers and emphasises the importance of agreeing any changes with the employee before implementing them.
What can we do to help you?
We are here to guide you through any tricky sickness issues you are having with employees, whether short term or long term. We can help with occupational health (OH) referrals and advising on what adjustments may be considered "reasonable" in the circumstances.
We also offer an OH service to our clients, enabling us to communicate with the OH provider directly to ensure you receive the most helpful report in the circumstances.
If you wish to discuss a particular situation with us or would like more information on the OH service we offer, please feel free to contact us at enquiries@judicium.com or call 0845 459 7013.
Related content
(4)(2)(1)(2).png)
The ERA is introducing increased worker protections and in this article we will focus on the forthcoming changes to unfair dismissal and how to prepare. From January 2027, the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal claims will reduce from two years to six months. At the same time the cap on the unfair dismissal compensatory award will be abolished.
Because conflict in schools rarely begins with one big dramatic moment, and is far more likely to grow slowly through strained conversations, crossed wires, unspoken frustration and small disagreements that never quite get repaired, it can be surprisingly easy for a situation to become serious before anyone fully realises quite how far it’s gone.
.png)
People sit at the heart of every education setting. In this blog, we explore the People and Payroll Hierarchy of Needs and why getting the basics right is essential for building a thriving, supported workforce.
(4)(2)(1).png)
The ERA has introduced increased worker protections, and in this article, we will focus on the new protections for sexual harassment. From 6 April 2026, sexual harassment disclosures will be protected under whistleblowing law, and by October 2026, employers must take all reasonable steps to prevent harassment, including liability for third-party actions.
Judicium Education has been shortlisted for the MAT Excellence Awards 2026 in Company of the Year and Trust Collaboration categories.
.png)
In this blog, we will explore effective strategies that school and academy trust leaders can use to attract top talent and sustain a strong, successful team for ongoing success.
Whats New | HR